Scholars See Real Threat to Democracy. Who's Ready to Believe Them?

Wednesday, June 16, 2021

If I were to ask Jim Lyons, the former Andover state rep and ardent Trump supporter who chairs of the Massachusetts Republican Party, what he thinks of the "Statement of Concern" issued earlier this month by a large group of "scholars of democracy," including 21 professors from Massachusetts, I'm pretty sure he'd dismiss their concerns as so much partisan twaddle.

In their statement, titled "The Threats to American Democracy and the Need for National Voting and Election Administration Standards," the scholars say they're watching with "deep concern as Republican-led state legislatures across the country have in recent months proposed or implemented what we consider radical changes to core electoral procedures in response to unproven and intentionally destructive allegations of a stolen election."

These are the same changes that Lyons and millions of other Republican regard as much-needed improvements ensuring the security and integrity of our elections.

And where the scholars see states like Florida and Georgia enacting laws that betray "our precious democratic heritage,"  Lyons et al. see far-left Democrats stirring people up with wild exaggerations and leading them astray with falsehoods and phony, inflated rhetoric. 

Me, I'm looking at the scholars as I would a group of highly credentialed and experienced physicians.  If my primary care doctor were to recommend that I consult one or more of them on a medical issue of some import, I might wish to ignore that advice and hope my problem went away on its own; nevertheless, I would make the necessary appointments and follow any directives the specialists might give me.  It's better to be safe than sorry, alive than dead 

These scholars could be right.

And if the U.S. Congress fails to do as they are now urging it to do -- enact federal legislation to establish uniform, nationwide standards for voting access and election procedures -- America could cease to exist as we have known it for 200-plus years and become instead an authoritarian nation masquerading as a democracy, as is now the case in Turkey, Hungary and other countries.

When the stakes are this high, every citizen should at the least read with an open mind and heart what these academics are saying in their unprecedented "Statement of Concern."

The complete text of their statement follows.  After that, I list the names of the Massachusetts signatories, and after that, I cite the views of a particular U.S. Senator on this subject.

We, the undersigned, are scholars of democracy who have watched the recent deterioration of U.S. elections and liberal democracy with growing alarm.  Specifically, we have watched with deep concern as Republican-led state legislatures across the country have in recent months proposed or implemented what we consider radical changes to core electoral procedures in response to unproven and intentionally destructive allegations of a stolen election.  Collectively, these initiatives are transforming several states into political systems that no longer meet the minimum conditions for free and fair elections.  Hence, our entire democracy is now at risk.

When democracy breaks down, it typically takes many years, often decades, to reverse the downward spiral.  In the process, violence and corruption typically flourish, and talent and wealth flee to more stable countries, undermining national prosperity.  It is not just our venerated institutions and norms that are at risk -- it is our future national standing, strength, and ability to compete globally.

Statutory changes in large key electoral battleground states are dangerously politicizing the process of electoral administration, with Republican-controlled legislatures giving themselves the power to override electoral outcomes on unproven allegations should Democrats win more votes.  They are seeking to restrict access to the ballot, the most basic principle underlying the right of all adult American citizens to participate in our democracy.  They are also putting in place criminal sentences and fines meant to intimidate and scare away poll workers and nonpartisan administrators.  State legislatures have advanced initiatives that curtail voting methods now preferred by Democratic-leaning constituencies, such as early voting and mail voting.  Republican lawmakers have openly talked about ensuring the "purity" and "equality" of the vote, echoing arguments widely used across the Jim Crow South as reasons for restricting the Black vote.

State legislators supporting these changes have cited the urgency of "electoral integrity" and the need to ensure that elections are secure and free of fraud.  But by multiple expert judgments, the 2020 election was extremely secure and free of fraud.  The reason that Republican voters have concerns is because many Republican officials, led by former President Trump, have manufactured false claims of fraud, claims that have been repeatedly rejected by courts of law, and which Trump's own lawyers have acknowledged were mere speculation when they testified about them before judges.

In future elections, these laws politicizing the administration and certification of elections could enable some state legislatures or partisan election officials to do what they failed to do in 2020: reverse the outcome of a free and fair election.  Further, these laws could entrench extended minority rule, violating the basic and longstanding democratic principle that parties that get the most votes should win elections.

Democracy rests on certain elemental institutional and normative conditions.  Elections must be neutrally and fairly administered.  They must be free of manipulation.  Every citizen who is qualified must have an equal right to vote, unhindered by obstruction.  And when they lose elections, political parties and their candidates and supporters must be willing to accept defeat and acknowledge the legitimacy of the outcome.  The refusal of prominent Republicans to accept the outcome of the 2020 election, and the anti-democratic laws adopted (or approaching adoption) in Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Montana and Texas -- and under consideration in other Republican-controlled states -- violate these principles.  More profoundly, these actions call into question whether the United States will remain a democracy.  As scholars of democracy, we condemn these actions in the strongest possible terms as a betrayal of our precious democratic heritage.

The most effective remedy for these anti-democratic laws at the state level is federal action to protect equal access of all citizens to the ballot and to guarantee free and fair elections.  Just as it ultimately took federal voting rights law to put an end to state-led voter suppression laws throughout the South, so federal law must once again ensure that American citizens' voting rights do not depend on which party or faction happens to be dominant in their state legislature, and that votes are cast and counted equally, regardless of the state or jurisdiction in which a citizen happens to live.  This is widely recognized as a fundamental principle of electoral integrity in democracies around the world.

A new voting rights law (such as that proposed in the John Lewis Voting Rights Act) is essential but alone is not enough.  True electoral integrity demands a comprehensive set of national standards that ensure the sanctity and independence of election administration, guarantee that all voters can freely exercise their right to vote, prevent partisan gerrymandering from giving dominant parties in the states an unfair advantage in the process of drawing congressional districts, and regulate ethics and money in politics.

It is always far better for major democracy reforms to be bipartisan, to give change the broadest possible legitimacy.  However, in the current hyper-polarized political context such broad bipartisan support is sadly lacking.  Elected Republican leaders have had numerous opportunities to repudiate Trump and his "Stop the Steal" crusade, which led to the violent attack on the U.S. Capitol on January 6.  Each time, they have sidestepped the truth and enabled the lie to spread.

We urge members of Congress to do whatever is necessary -- including suspending the filibuster -- in order to pass national voting and election administration standards that both guarantee the vote to all Americans equally, and prevent state legislatures from manipulating the rules in order to manufacture the result they want.  Our democracy is fundamentally at stake.  History will judge what we do at this moment.

MASSACHUSETTS SIGNATORIES 

Daniel Carpenter, Professor of Government, Harvard University

Daniel W. Drezner, Professor of International Politics, Tufts University

Archon Fung, Professor of Citizenship and Self-Government, Harvard University

Jill S. Greenlee, Associate Professor of Politics, Brandeis University

Jennifer Hochschild, Professor of Government, Harvard University

Alexander Keyssar, Professor of History and Social Policy, Harvard University

Daniel Kryder, Associate Professor of Politics, Brandeis University

Peter Levine, Professor, Tisch College, Tufts University

Steve Levitsky, Professor of Government, Harvard University

Jane Mansbridge, Professor Emerita of Political Leadership and Democratic Values, Harvard University

Pippa Norris, Professor of Political Science, Harvard University

Robert D. Putnam, Professor of Public Policy, Harvard University

Miles S. Rapoport, Senior Practice Fellow in American Democracy, Harvard University

Nancy L. Rosenblum, Professor Emerita of Ethics in Politics and Government, Harvard University

Virginia Sapiro, Professor of Political Science, Boston University

Kay L. Schlozman, Associate Professor of Political Science, Boston College

Alan D. Solomont, Dean, Tisch College, Tufts University

Alexander George Theodoridis, Associate Professor of Political Science, University of Massachusetts Amherst

Alejandro Trelles, Assistant Professor of Politics, Brandeis University

Lawrence H. Tribe, Professor Emeritus of Constitutional Law, Harvard Law School

Daniel Ziblatt, Professor of Government, Harvard University

"AN INCREDIBLY DANGEROUS MOMENT"

Senator Angus King, an independent from Maine, was interviewed by The New York Times as part of its reporting for an article published June 14 under this headline: "In Congress, Republicans Shrug at Warnings of Democracy in Peril."

King, a former professor of American politics at Bowdoin College, was quoted as describing our democracy as a "240-year experiment that runs against the tide of human history."  That tide, he noted, usually leads from, and back to, authoritarianism.

"This is an incredibly dangerous moment," King said, "and I don't think it's being sufficiently realized as such."



My Path to Memorial Day Goes Through the 1919 Boston Police Strike

Monday, May 31, 2021

I've heard politics described as the way decisions are made on who gets what.  Its hard to dispute that.  

Nearly 102 years ago, in September of 1919, four out of five members of the Boston police force took a big political gamble: they went on strike to win official recognition of their right to form a union.  They wanted more pay, shorter shifts and better working conditions. 

Not only did the strikers not succeed, they all promptly lost their jobs.  

Massachusetts Governor Calvin Coolidge declared, "There is no right to strike against the public safety by anybody, anywhere, anytime," a popular stance that made him a national figure and inspired the Republican Party to put him on its national ticket the next year as Warren Harding's running mate.  When Harding died in 1923, Coolidge became president.  

There's nothing like a crisis to boost (or break) a political career.  Were it not for the Boston Police Strike, Coolidge never would have become president.

My family has a link to that milestone event in the history of Boston and of the nation.  My mother's older brother, John F. Doyle, was in a Yankee Division National Guard unit activated by Coolidge during the strike to restore order to a city suddenly lacking most of its police officers.  Rabble- rousers, hooligans and looters had quickly come out of the woodwork.  

Here's how Brian MacQuarrie of The Boston Globe, writing two years ago on the centennial of the strike, memorably described what was happening on the streets of Boston at that time:

"...sword-waving cavalry charged into a jeering, stone-throwing crowd of 15,000 people in downtown Boston.  Roaming mobs robbed bystanders and looted stores.  Part-time infantry from the suburbs and small Massachusetts towns fired into crowds, fixed bayonets against Bostonians, and shot eight people dead over four tumultuous days."

MacQuarrie wrote that the event "was the country's first major police strike, and it caused a national uproar, feeding fears of revolution and communist infiltration at a time of growing labor unrest." The strike, he noted, was the first time Boston "had been placed under military watch" since the Revolutionary War.

Private Doyle was only 19 when called to strike duty.  He had enlisted in the Army after graduating from Revere High School, wanting to serve in World War I, but the war ended before he could be sent overseas.  He then became a reservist.

I never knew my Uncle John.  He died long before I was born.  I heard a lot about him, however, from my mother, who was one of 13 Doyle children.   He was known for his devotion to his mother and father, his kindness to all of his siblings, his smile and naturally good disposition.  He was not a big guy or a tough guy.  I have always had trouble squaring that reality with the image of a young, untested soldier carrying a rifle on the streets of Boston, with orders to shoot looters on sight.  If he ever fired his weapon during the strike, I think it would have become part of family lore.

There is an anecdote about Uncle John's service that has always stuck in my mind.  His father, Joseph Doyle, an immigrant from Ireland, had returned home from work on the second day of the strike to learn that his second child (and the oldest of his six sons) had been activated and was already likely in Boston.  Worried that his son would not be warm enough if he had to sleep on sidewalks or in doorways, my grandfather took his winter overcoat from a closet and headed to Boston on foot. He hiked from his home on Central Avenue in Revere, down Broadway and all the way through Chelsea, where at the shore of Boston Harbor he caught a ferry to the North End.  Having no idea where his son might be, he started asking the soldiers he encountered if they knew where his son's unit was stationed.  In time, he found the unit and his son.  "Pa," as he was called, handed John the overcoat, shook his hand, and turned right around toward home, not getting there until just before midnight.  Whenever I think about his long walk into and out of a city filled with danger, I'm impressed anew by the love he had for his children.

Within months of the Boston Police Strike, Uncle John became ill with respiratory problems.  The eventual diagnosis was one of the grimmest for that era: tuberculosis.  Because of his youth and vigor, he was able to put up a good fight for a long time.  There were times when he felt better and seemed to be on the verge of a cure.  But he never got clear of the TB.  Uncle John died on a summer morning in 1933 as the nation he had served staggered through the Great Depression.  By then, his father had been dead for almost two years, also from TB.

The U.S. Army determined that Private Doyle's fatal illness was service-related and granted a small survivor's pension to his mother.  When it arrived in the mail, my grandmother would always refer to the monthly stipend as "John's check."   It turned out to be a critical support to the family he left behind.

After his death, the City of Revere dedicated a triangular strip of land at the intersection of Suffolk and Prospect Avenues as John F. Doyle Square.  In 2013, the members of my extended family managed to have the square re-dedicated.  John's only sibling alive at that time, my Aunt Arlene, astonishingly quick of mind and step at age 86, was the heart and soul of that event.

Since then, on every Memorial Day, I and a first cousin of mine, Christine, have planted flowers around the stone erected for the rededication of "John's Square," as we all call it. That is what we will be doing later today, hoping the while that there's no more rain to fall this weekend.  

Although neither of us ever knew our Uncle John, the example of his life has always been very alive and real to us -- and to all of the other many Doyle family survivors out there.  We remain grateful to our grandmother, who lived into the late-1960s, and to John's brothers and sisters, for inculcating in us an appreciation of all that he was -- not a hero, but certainly a patriot, a strong-hearted, citizen-boy-soldier willing to put his life on the line for his country and the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.








MA Congressional Delegation in the Right Place on Filibuster: Kill. Now.

Tuesday, May 25, 2021

I was talking years ago with another lobbyist at a charity fundraiser at a Boston hotel when a former state representative known to both of us happened to walk into the crowded function hall where the event took place. Everybody I knew who knew this ex-rep liked the guy because he was as charming as can be and the opposite of a fathead.  We both shook his hand enthusiastically and exchanged greetings with him as he squeezed past us.  When the ex-rep was out of earshot, I said to the other guy, "You knew him when he served.  What was he like as a legislator?"  My brother-in-advocacy smiled faintly, then offered a succinct assessment: "He liked everything about the job but the voting."

The memory of that encounter has popped into my head more then once in the time since Joe Biden was elected president, his party took control of the Senate, and widespread speculation began on whether Democrats would attempt to eliminate the filibuster, a procedural mechanism that allows any senator to block action indefinitely on a pending bill.  The obstruction may only be removed if a minimum of 60 senators vote to override the filibuster, meaning nothing significant can win passage in the Senate without the support of at least 60 of the 100 members of the upper branch.  

The filibuster is not ordained by the Constitution.  It is an optional rule the Senate chooses to impose upon itself, even though it runs counter to a basic standard of democracy, i.e., the majority rules, and even though it allows a relatively small number of senators to constantly thwart the will of the majority.

Proponents of the filibuster assert that it serves as a salutary inducement to bi-partisan lawmaking.  The reality is that it motivates the party in the minority in the Senate at any given time to slap away the hand of the majority so as to stymie its agenda and render the majority impotent in the eyes of the electorate, and thus more likely to lose its majority in the next election.

The filibuster is a formula for endless gridlock in our time.  There are many reasons to eliminate it, and I'm at the point where any reason is good enough for me.  My personal favorite is that it has become a gigantic wall for senators to hide behind, a place where they crouch when they should be standing up and making a stand.  

If the former state representative I mentioned at the top of this post were now a senator serving at the Capitol, he'd be both feet in for the filibuster.

Democrats and Republicans have both played the filibuster game shamelessly through the years.  The game requires the party in the minority to cry that, if the majority does away with the filibuster, the spirit of bipartisanship and all inter-party comity will be forever banished from the chamber.  

"And be careful what you wish for," the minority warns.  "The next time you're out of power, you'll rue the day you destroyed the filibuster."  

The minority also warns, "Next time we're in power, we'll overturn everything you did with your majority-only votes.  So what would be the point?"

I think it's a crock that what our nation most needs now is less political divisiveness and more  bi-partisanship in lawmaking.  What we need is the party in the majority, which happens to be Democrat at this time, to enact its legislative priorities so that when November of 2022 rolls around, Americans will have a definite idea -- as opposed to a suspicion or a hope -- of what they are voting for or against.

I'm not saying the Democrat agenda is ideal, or that it is sure to produce marvelous results if enacted, only that we should vote for or against it in November of 2022 based on what it is actually accomplishing, as opposed to what the Rupert Murdochs of the world predict it would do to the country if the filibuster was not there to stop it.

We elect people to go to Washington and make decisions for us.  (In a rational world, the Congress would always make the toughest issues a priority for deciding because those are the ones that would produce the greatest good if resolved correctly and swiftly.)   Deciding means voting.  Not voting means delay, which means the compounding of problems.  Not voting is a bad deal for the people.

It is an ironclad law of politics that elections have consequences.  The filibuster is an unnatural interference in the operation of that law.

I'll wrap up with a shout-out to members of the Congress from Massachusetts who unequivocally want to kill the filibuster...  

Not long after Biden was elected, our two U.S. Senators, Elizabeth Warren and Edward Markey, clearly re-stated their desire to see the filibuster eliminated.  

And, on April 22, six of our nine U.S. representatives -- Jake Auchincloss, Katherine Clark, Jim McGovern, Seth Moulton, Ayanna Pressley and Lori Trahan -- joined 93 of their House colleagues in signing a letter to Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer urging him to do all he can to strike it from Senate procedures.  

That letter said, in part:

"In today's hyper-partisan climate, there is simply no avenue for bold legislation that meets the needs of everyday Americans without ending the filibuster.  Just last month, we witnessed one of this Congress's and President Biden's core promises, increasing the federal minimum wage to $15, fail to be included in the American Rescue Plan...

"...the path forward in the fight for the $15 (minimum wage), voting rights, climate and environmental justice, gun violence prevention, immigration reform, worker protections, LGBTQ equality, and reforming our criminal-legal system will likely be further obstructed -- unless we end the filibuster.

"...what has become patently clear is that we cannot let a procedural tool that can be abolished stand in the way of justice, prosperity, and equity..."

Amen.












This Moment in Chicanery: Electricity Marketplace Bait and Switch

Saturday, April 24, 2021

I learned two things from a recent (April 9) letter to my wife and me from a fund administrator for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts:  I don't know the first thing about buying electricity, and our attorney general looks out for dopes like me.

"Thank you for being a valued customer of Starion Energy," the letter said.  "On August 18, 2020, Starion Energy entered into a final judgment by consent with the Massachusetts Office of the Attorney General (the 'AGO').  The final judgment resolves the AGO's claims that Starion Energy, Inc. ('Starion') did not comply with certain provisions of the Massachusetts Consumer Protection laws in the course of marketing and selling Starion's electricity supply.  Although Starion denied the claims by the AGO, Starion has nevertheless agreed to establish a fund for the benefit of certain of its current and former customers."

The letter further said, "The Independent Administrator who administers the Fund has determined that you are eligible to receive reimbursement for a portion of what you have paid to Starion Energy for electricity supply services and/or fees.  Accordingly, enclosed is a check in the amount that the Administrator has determined is appropriate."

That check was for $263.33.  

We cashed it right away.  

Then I proceeded to find out why they sent us the dough. 

Online, I found a copy of a March 5 press release from AG Maura Healey's office announcing that customers of Starion were beginning to receive restitution payments as part of a settlement of allegations that it had used "unfair and deceptive sales tactics to lure more than 100,000 Massachusetts customers into expensive contracts with high electricity rates." 

These customers were collectively charged "millions more on their bills than they would have paid if they stayed with their utility company," the release said.

Healey was quoted thusly, "This company falsely promised thousands of Massachusetts customers big savings on their electricity bills, but instead overcharged them...We're glad to be returning more than $7 million to customers harmed by Starion's deceptive tactics."

The release cited a 2018 lawsuit accusing Starion, a company headquartered in Middlebury, CT, of violating Massachusetts consumer protection laws "by engaging in unfair sales tactics, including unsolicited telemarketing calls and pre-recorded robocalls that falsely promised customers lower electricity rates."

I asked my wife, "Do you remember our switching to this company?"

"Vaguely," she said. "A few years ago, I think it was, I spoke with a salesperson a couple of times who was saying how much money we could save on electricity."

"We must have talked it over then, but I can't remember that talk," I said.

She said, "You said something like, 'If we can save a few bucks, why not?' "

I said, "Do you remember what happened to our bills after switching?"

"The best I can recall, they went down for three or four months, then started going up," she said. "Before long, they were as high, if not higher, than before. I just figured, there's no beating the system."

"By the way," she added, "did you ever give electricity bills another thought?"

"Not once," I had to admit.

"How surprising," she said.

On the day we were having this conversation, there happened to be a letter in the pile of mail on our kitchen table from a different energy supplier offering to sell us electricity for three years at a guaranteed price of 10.99 cents per kilowatt hour.  

In a stab at being serious about our personal finances, I emailed a friend who knows a lot about electricity prices on account of his job.

"Is 10.99 cents a KW hour for three years a good deal, a smart move?" I wrote.

"I'm not a big fan of competitive supply options," he wrote back, "because the onus is on you to have to remember, and pursue, when your contract is up.  By contrast, your local municipal aggregator of electricity purchasers offers the same basic idea as a competitive supplier, without the mailings -- and with the bargaining power of more load-users, taking the need to do all the research off your shoulders.  As a result, what your aggregator is offering may not be the 'best' deal on the market at any particular time, but it usually involves less stress."

Yesterday, taking my friend's lead, I visited the website of the City of Melrose and filled out a form to enroll us as subscribers in the "Local Green" default (or standard) product offered by Melrose Community Power.  At the moment I enrolled, this product was priced at 10.521 cents per kilowatt hour.  

There was a feel-good aspect to the decision: at least 5% of the power we'll consume this way will always come from renewable sources.






 


MA Blue Cross Blue Shield CEO on Chauvin Conviction: 'Much Work Needs to Be Done'

Wednesday, April 21, 2021

Today, many organizations in Massachusetts issued statements on the conviction yesterday of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin in the murder of George Floyd.  All were good and worthwhile.  And one of the best came from Andrew Dreyfus, president and chief executive officer of Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts and a veteran of the Michael Dukakis administration.  

Dreyfus's statement was directed primarily at the company's 3,700 employees.  Here it is in its entirety:

"Many of us today are reflecting on the guilty verdict in the murder of George Floyd.  For the past week, our board member Quincy Miller noted, 'it has felt like our very humanity was on trial.'  In the end, Mr. Floyd's humanity was recognized.  His life mattered.

"And his death mattered.  Mr. Floyd's senseless killing, at the hands of a police officer sworn to protect him, spurred outrage and anguish in America, as well as vital dialogue and action.

"One verdict does not mark victory in a long fight for justice and accountability, but I hope it does mark progress in a battle that will continue.  We know we can only begin to heal as a nation if we act together to address racism and injustice.

"Our company is committed to racial justice and committed to doing the hard work of healing.  We are confronting the crisis of racial health inequities and working to create a more equitable health care system, especially for people of color.  We are supporting Black and Brown leaders in our community, including organizations focused on police reform.  Working together, we can begin to put an end to inequities.

"Much work remains to be done, in our company and in our community.

"Here at Blue Cross, we will continue our dialogues on racial equity and prejudice, including at next month's Company Connect and in June when, for the first time as a company, we mark Juneteenth, the day that commemorates the end of slavery.

"Racial injustice and bias bring pain and fear to members of our own community, and I have been proud to see our associates support each other and show solidarity.  Today, I encourage you to connect with others -- check on colleagues, reach out if you are feeling hurt.  We can take strength from our common values of respect, dignity, and equity for all."


Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts has nearly three million members.  Dreyfus has been a part of the organization's executive team since 2005 and its president/CEO since 2010.  Before that, he served for years in the leadership of the Massachusetts Hospital Association (MHA).

I got to know him back in the last century when working in public relations for community hospitals. I served for a spell on an MHA committee dealing with public affairs, which he staffed, and have since bumped into him occasionally at the State House or on a downtown sidewalk -- meetings all too rare for my liking.

If you ever want to encounter a truly upright human being, if you ever want (or need) the experience of being unmistakably in the presence of goodness, seek an encounter with Andrew Dreyfus.  



 

Massachusetts Has Billions of Reasons to Be Grateful to Uncle Sam

Sunday, April 11, 2021

There's a Chinese proverb that says, "When you drink from the stream, remember the spring."

Pondering that ancient wisdom, I find myself asking: post-pandemic, will we in Massachusetts -- and our counterparts in the 49 other states of the union -- ever remember all that our federal government did to secure our lives and our standard of living in 2020 and in 2021?

If I were a betting man, I'd bet no. We certainly will not remember.

I believe that another proverb, reputedly an Irish one, holds sway in this situation; it says, "Eaten bread is soon forgotten."

And that is a shame.  

When we finally get our lives back to normal in these divided states of America, we will need a sustained swelling of collective gratitude. There will be no better way to leach the venom from our politics, rebuild the spirit of the nation, and begin the no-longer-avoidable process of truly uniting (and treating equitably) all Americans. 

Let's turn to a select few of the more recent reasons why we in the Bay State should thank God we had a federal government to fall back upon when all was cracking and folding in Massachusetts under the attack of the coronavirus...

According to a Massachusetts Taxpayers Foundation analysis of the Biden administration's recently enacted American Rescue Plan (ARP), Massachusetts will receive $4.5 billion in flexible Coronavirus State Fiscal Recovery Funds, "as well as billions in targeted assistance for programs closely linked to budget line items."

That targeted assistance will include $1.8 billion to support public schools, $1 billion to keep the MBTA and regional transit authorities operating, $510 million for early child care, $450 million for emergency rental and foreclosure assistance, $174.4 million for programs created under a new Coronavirus Capital Projects Fund, and $150 million "to support the state's public health workforce."

There's more!

The ARP, for example, is expected to deliver $3.4 billion directly to municipal governments throughout Massachusetts, ensuring the continuation of vital local services and the jobs and paychecks of tens of thousands of municipal employees.

And, in a significant development apart from the ARP, the Biden administration has extended a federal public health emergency, which will lead to federal dollars covering most of a massive shortfall that otherwise would have occurred in MassHealth/Medicaid. the health coverage program for approximately 1.7 million residents.

I understand anyone who rejects the be-grateful-to-Uncle-Sam argument.  

People can legitimately say, This is my government, this is what it is supposed to do in a crisis, and, anyway, we the public are going to have to pay eventually for the borrowing of the trillions in federal aid we are rapidly consuming.

But I'll never buy that.

Too conveniently, too self-servingly, that kind of thinking ignores the simple good luck that has made us all Americans, by birth or immigration, and thus eligible to partake of the fruits of the world's largest economy and its most trusted currency.   

I'm so far into the other corner that I'll jump on the bandwagon of the first politician to propose that, starting next year, we make October 1, the first day of the federal fiscal year, an official day of remembrance, "Federal Government Appreciation Day," on which we stop and ponder how bad things could have been, how desperate we and our families could have become, if our government couldn't, or wouldn't, have borrowed our way out of this crisis.

UPDATE, 4-30-21:  According to tabulations by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, Massachusetts has received more federal relief aid, per capita, during the COVID-19 national emergency than all but two states and the District of Columbia.  The top five per capita amounts recipients are: Washington, D.C., $12,845; New York, $10,881; Vermont, $10,340; Massachusetts, $9,893; North Dakota, $9,844.  Summarizing the foundation's report on this subject, the State House News Service on April 26 wrote: "As of April 15, Massachusetts had received $69.19 billion in federal assistance dating back to the start of the pandemic, which the foundation said was the 11th most of any state.  About $20.5 billion of that came in the form of Paycheck Protection Program loans, and another $11.36 billion was for federal pandemic unemployment compensation."

                                                                                                                                                                                                         





Never Thought I'd See This: Newspapers Dying, MA Legislators Want to Help

Wednesday, March 31, 2021

As part of a recently enacted economic development bill, An Act Enabling Partnerships for Growth, a special legislative commission will shortly be established to look at how some communities are now "underserved by local journalism," and what may be done to improve that situation.   

I think the legislature could have come up with a better way to describe the problem.  We're talking here about the widespread die-off of local, independent newspapers due to the loss of advertising dollars to the internet.  "Underserved by local journalism" sounds like lazy reporters and distracted publishers may be to blame.

But I shouldn't quibble with lawmakers for choosing words the way they've always chosen them, especially when I am delighted they have taken on the issue.  

Nothing better than a good local newspaper has ever been devised to let people know what they really must about their community, and to hold the feet of the folks who run that community to the fire.  Where newspapers are professionally advanced and financially healthy, community spirit is more tangible, local politicking is more robust, and the climate for civic engagement is more favorable.

It's difficult to quantify all the ruin when a newspaper goes belly up, or when a revenue-starved paper shrinks to a shadow of its former self, turning from lightning rod to object of pity and derision.  (The actual, new term for such publications is "ghost newspapers.")  Certainly, the human toll is enormous.

Since 2000, newspaper employment has dropped by 60%.  That's a higher percentage than all the jobs lost in coal mining over the last 30 years.

In a Jan. 1, 2020, report on PBS News Hour, Charles Sennot observed, "When we lose 30,000 reporting jobs, as we have in the last 10 years, what we lose is the ability for us to have a shared set of facts on a local level, and for us to have a civic debate on the local level.  And I think we're seeing a fraying of communities as well."  

Two North Shore Democrats, Senator Brendan Crighton of Lynn and Rep. Lori Ehrlich of Marblehead, led the call for government to do something to fortify local journalism, first by introducing a stand-alone bill on the matter, which got stalled in the legislature, and then by ensuring that a version of the bill would be incorporated into the voluminous, multi-purpose economic development bill, which was passed on the last day of the 2019-20 legislative session, Jan. 5, 2021, and signed into law by Governor Baker nine days later.

In an interview afterward with the Lynn Item, Ehrlich said, "A lack of local news coverage is a fundamental threat to our democracy and civic society.  Citizens rely on hardworking journalists to tell the stories that bind us together as communities.  Trusted news sources provide a public square where shared facts and thoughtful opinion enable us to hold power to account and govern ourselves."

Ehrlich added, "With this commission, the Commonwealth will facilitate a serious discussion among experts, reporters and industry members about the state of local news in Massachusetts, and what fortification efforts can take place."

Also speaking with the Lynn Item, Crighton said, "Now, more than ever, we need a strong and robust news media to keep our citizenry as informed as possible and to ensure accountability."

Amen.

I do not have much of a concept of what this commission can actually do to halt and/or reverse the seemingly inexorable diminution of local reporting, but I dearly hope it can accomplish something.

I started my working life as a newspaper reporter for a small daily, the Chelsea Record, and stayed with the trade for more than a dozen years.  My final news job was managing editor of the Malden Evening News.  That was a good place and a good time to be in local journalism.  We had six full-time reporters covering the City of Malden, all paid a livable, union wage.  The Malden Evening News and its affiliated publications, the Medford Daily Mercury and the Melrose Evening News, employed more than 70 persons at their peak.  Three bargaining units represented the interests of the majority of those workers: the Newspaper Guild, the Typesetters and Compositors, and the Pressmen's unions.   As journalists, we were far from perfect, but we covered the community vigorously and as fairly as possible, and in a way it is no longer covered.  My old outfit, after years of slow decline and a spell as a ghost newspaper, closed for good several years ago.

Back in the late-1970s, the newspaper business was so good that the principal owner-publisher of the Evening News/Daily Mercury group, David Brickman, moved the operation from its cramped, dingy quarters on Ferry Street, in Malden Square, to a new, larger, better equipped plant on Commercial Street, in the largest of the city's urban renewal districts.  On the marble cornerstone of that new edifice, Mr. Brickman had these words engraved: "Bulwark of Freedom."  A new owner totally remodeled and reconfigured the former home of the News-Mercury, including the main door and facade.  The cornerstone, I'm pretty sure, was tossed into a dumpster.  We should hope that its fate was not premonitory.