This Moment in Corruption: AG Settles False, Inflated Billing Cases

Saturday, March 27, 2021

Since 2016, the office of Attorney General Maura Healey has successfully prosecuted three home health agencies and their owners for defrauding MassHealth, the state's Medicaid program, and has settled civil actions against nine home health agencies similarly accused of improper billing.

During federal fiscal year 2020 alone, AG Healey's Medicaid Fraud Division recovered more than $45 million from companies and individuals participating in the MassHealth system, which provides health care coverage to approximately 23% of the Massachusetts populace.

In ongoing efforts in this vein, AG Healey announced this past Thursday that her office had reached a settlement with a Lawrence-based home health care company and its owner that resolved allegations of falsely billing MassHealth for services "not properly authorized by a physician."

The AG reported that Lifod Home Health Care LLC  and the company's chief executive, Kariuki Kimungu, will pay $1.25 million to resolve allegations that, since May 1, 2015, "they knowingly submitted false claims to MassHealth and managed care entities administering services to MassHealth members for unauthorized home health" care.

"This kind of illegal conduct takes funds away from MassHealth, which provides critical health care to low-income and vulnerable residents across the state," said Healey.  "We are committed to combatting fraud, waste, and abuse in the home health industry and will continue to take action against companies that don't abide by state laws and regulations."

To bill MassHealth for home health services, a provider must ensure that the member's physician has reviewed and signed a plan of care certifying that home health services are medically necessary.  Home health agencies are required to maintain patient care records for at least six years after the medical services are provided and claims have been presented for payment.  The AG's Office alleged that Lifod billed for services "for which it did not have valid, signed plans of care..."

In addition to the financial payment, the settlement also included a requirement that Lifod "...operate under a multi-year compliance program, overseen by an independent compliance reviewer.  That program will include updated policies and procedures, new training for staff, and yearly audits conducted by the reviewer."

The AG maintains a broad focus to ensure that private entities doing business with the Commonwealth do not take advantage of the public purse.  

This past Monday, for example, the AG's office announced that a consulting company doing business in multiple states reached a civil settlement of allegations that it had inflated bills on public works projects in Massachusetts, New York and New Jersey.

Under that settlement, V.J. Associates, Inc. of New England and an affiliated company, VJ Associates,  agreed to pay back $1.8 million, with $195,871 going to Massachusetts.

A press release from the office stated that the investigation began after a whistleblower, a former employee of VJ Associates, filed a complaint under the Massachusetts False Claims Act, which allows individuals to file civil actions on behalf of the government and share in any recovered proceeds.

VJ Associates provided cost estimating and scheduling services as subcontractors on more than 100 public works projects throughout the Commonwealth.  

AG Healey's investigation "revealed that VJ Associates was engaged in an overbilling scheme in which it would routinely inflate hours worked on projects paid on an hourly basis," the press release said.  "Under pressure from management, employees openly discussed and described improper billing in emails as 'juicing' and 'tagging' hours in order to 'maximize' bills on government projects and not 'leave money on the table.' "

As part of this agreement, the AG reported, "VJ Associates admitted to submitting false bills and agreed to be debarred from submitting bids or being awarded any public works contracts with the Commonwealth of Massachusetts or any other government entity within the state for a period of five years."


Blogster's Miscellany: Moments in Time for Galvin, Guv and Senator Ed

Tuesday, March 16, 2021

GOP GAGGING ON GALVIN'S 'GREAT DAY' THEME: Secretary of State William F. Galvin is a leader in the Democratic charge to make our temporary, expanded mail-in voting system permanent  and finds himself clashing regularly with Republicans who strongly oppose the move.  Former Andover state rep and current MA GOP Chairman Jim Lyons has said, "A permanent system where unsupervised voting is the norm, held in settings that are unsecure, is no way to ensure electoral integrity.  We hold election day for a reason, and we vote in person for a reason, and it all has to do with ensuring that the public has no doubts as to the integrity of the results."  Voting by mail was expanded for last fall's elections in response to the pandemic and should not continue once the crisis has passed, Republicans believe.  To make those changes permanent would be "inviting chaos," asserts John Paul Moran, an MIT-educated scientist and Republican who ran unsuccessfully against Democrat incumbent Seth Moulton in the Sixth Congressional District this past November.  Moran has also said "the responsibility should be with Secretary Galvin to prove that (election) fraud did not and will not happen."  Galvin does indeed have overall responsibility for ensuring fair and honest elections in Massachusetts.  His record demonstrates that he has always taken that responsibility very seriously.  He is a lawyer and has been Secretary of State for 26 years; he knows more about elections than anyone alive today in Massachusetts.  When Galvin declared the Nov. 3 election "a great day for democracy in Massachusetts," that had more than superficial meaning.  Galvin told reporters on Nov. 19, while calling for the incoming Biden administration to start an obstruction of justice investigation into President Trump's calls to election officials in Michigan while votes were still being counted there: "...in Massachusetts, we have not had or experienced some of the problems that other states have had.  And when I say problems, the problems have not been with (our) election administrators.  The problems have been with the concerted effort by the Trump campaign to intimidate, threaten, and, in some cases, I suggest, engage in obstruction of justice with the process."  The number of Massachusetts voters who participated in the Nov. 3 election totaled 3,657,972, which was nearly 300,000 more than voted in November, 2016, the highest previous total before that.  Expanded mail-in voting made that record-breaking participation possible.  "I am thrilled that turnout in this election exceeded even my own high expectations," Galvin said.  "Even in the midst of a global pandemic, our voters showed up in the ways that worked best for them, whether it was on election day, by mail, or during early voting."  More Massachusetts citizens voted than ever before and there was no fraud.  Shouldn't we be celebrating that fact and the local election officials in our 351 cities and towns who helped make Nov. 3 "a great day for Democracy in Massachusetts" -- a trouble-free, crime-free election?  Shouldn't we be confident all of these officials could do it again smoothly and honestly two or four years from now?  Or must we regard any future election built on the model of Nov. 3 as we would a sales pitch for time-shares in Florida, that is, with suspicion and fear, as Mr. Lyons, et al., would have it?

BAKER NEVER TELLS A CHARITY, "BUZZ OFF:"  Every year he's served as governor, Charlie Baker has had his hair buzzcut as part of the "Saving by Shaving" fundraiser for Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston.  The latest cut took place this past Wednesday.  As I've said before in this blog, Baker's willingness to have his enviable head of hair cut to three-eighths of an inch all over demonstrates a commendable, manly indifference to his appearance.  It also evinces a lack of vanity not normally associated with prominent figures. Some celebrities and lots of average folks participate every year in "Saving by Shaving" -- the "saving" refers to the cancer patients given new leases on life  -- but I don't recall many politicians of high rank going this route. There are many politicians we can safely say would never have their hair mostly removed, on camera, in public, for charity.  Take, for example, Baker's fellow Republican, Donald Trump, whose long swoop of artificially colored hair must require elaborate manipulation (plus clouds of hairspray) every morning to achieve just the right helmet look.  You'll never see Trump perched amiably in a hotel function room while some volunteer rushes the clippers over that creation.  Baker said after his latest buzzcut, "I know this doesn't look very good.  But it doesn't look very good for a short period of time and it grows back...It's a moment and an opportunity for those of us who, thank God, don't have cancer to understand what it might be like to have cancer and to lose all your hair and to end up in a situation where you feel a little uncomfortable about the way you look."  This year, "Saving by Shaving" is expected to raise more than $7 million dollars.  Thanks for adding a significant chunk to that sum, Governor, and for leading by example.

WHEN MARKEY SAVED A TRUTH-TELLER:  The New York Times published a lengthy obituary on Allan McDonald, an engineer for Morton-Thiokol who tried unsuccessfully to delay the launch of the space shuttle Challenger on the fateful morning of Jan. 28, 1986, ["Allan McDonald Dies at 83; Tried to Stop the Challenger Launch," 3-9-21].  The write-up contained an account of how our state's junior senator, Ed Markey, prevented the company from later demoting McDonald in apparent retaliation for handing information to a presidential commission investigating the explosion that destroyed the Challenger soon after launch and caused the deaths of all seven astronauts aboard, including, most prominently, Christa McAuliffe, a Concord, NH, schoolteacher who had grown up in Massachusetts. Markey was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives at the time.  Because of how cold it was in Florida on the morning of the scheduled launch, McDonald, who was in charge of Morton-Thiokol's booster rocket program, was concerned that the rubber O-ring gaskets on the Challenger's booster rocket would become so stiff as to allow fuel to leak and cause an explosion.  He and another company engineer, Roger Boisjoly, argued that the launch should be postponed until the weather improved.  According to the Times, "Both Mr. McDonald and Mr. Boisjoly, who had provided internal Morton-Thiokol documents to the commission, were later punished by the company: Mr. McDonald was demoted and Mr. Boisjoly was placed on leave.  After Representative Edward Markey of Massachusetts learned about their treatment, he threatened to bar Morton-Thiokol from future government contracts unless it restored the two men to their positions."  After Markey intervened, McDonald was named a company vice president and put in charge of redesigning its booster rockets.  (Boisjoly apparently chose not return to the company.)  Like millions of others, I watched on TV the launch of the Challenger.  I remember most how the camera was trained, right after the shuttle lifted off, on the faces of McAuliffe's parents, Edward and Grace Corrigan, and how their expressions changed from excited and proud to alarmed and stricken when the ship faltered, veered off course and started falling.  They were stunned, uncomprehending.  The camera lingered on them until they slowly left the bleachers where they were stationed.  It truly hurt to witness the impact of the accident upon them in real time.  





Gun Manufacturers, Sellers Once Again Owe Big Thank You to Democrats

Monday, March 8, 2021

It's no coincidence that, with Democrats now in power in Washington, gun sales are booming.  The same thing happened in 2009 when Obama moved into the White House.

More people buy guns for the first time, and existing gun owners buy more guns, when the president is a Democrat because, fearing new gun control laws are coming, they give in to the urge to get firearms while they (supposedly) still can. 

This fear is good for gun manufacturers, including those who've long made their home in the south central part of Massachusetts, an industrial cluster that owes its birth to George Washington's decision to build the arsenal of the new United States of America in Springfield, far from the reach of the British navy and army.

Springfield-based Smith & Wesson, for example, reported this past Thursday that its gun sale totals more than doubled during the three months ending January 31.  Total sales were $257.6 million in that quarter, while during the same period the year before, total sales were $127.4 million. 

Massachusetts residents get caught up in the better-get-a-gun-while-I-can frenzy as much as anyone. It doesn't seem to matter that national gun control laws with real bite never get passed.

According to the federal Department of Criminal Justice Information Services, in 2020, there were 135,641 transactions involving the sale and transfer of handguns, rifles, shotguns or machine guns by Massachusetts firearms dealers to individuals who had a valid Massachusetts firearms license.  There were 89,277 such transactions in 2019, meaning firearms sales and transfers increased 34% in one year as Massachusetts residents apparently decided there was a good chance Trump would lose the presidency and they would lose a smooth path to gun ownership.  (According to a recent article in The [Springfield] Republican newspaper, the National Sports Foundation estimated that between 40% and 60% of persons acquiring firearms in 2020 were first-time buyers.)

It's not inexpensive to acquire a gun legally, and, when you do, you're saddled with the endless legal responsibility of possessing and handling a deadly weapon in a safe manner.  

It might feel good to have something you think will protect you in a very bad situation, such as a home invasion, but it comes with (a) the  realization you're not living in a Clint Eastwood movie, and, besides, you're no Clint Eastwood, and (b) the constant worry of keeping that weapon and its ammunition away from an innocent party, such as your child or grandchild or some kid from the neighborhood who wanders into your house one day.  

You own the gun, and it owns you.

Say you decided tomorrow to get yourself one of Smith & Wesson's most popular handguns, the 9 mm M&P Shield pistol.  You'll pay $606 for the pistol, plus $37.87 in sales tax (at rate of 6.25%).  Then you'll pay $100 for a the required license to carry a firearm in Massachusetts and $100 for the required Firearms Identification Card, but, even before you get that license and card, you'll pay $125 to take the required Massachusetts Basic Firearms Safety Course, which usually consists of one session of three to four hours.  You'll be out $968.87, and you would not yet have purchased any ammo or the locked containers you'll need to store them safely at home.  And you would not have purchased a membership in an organization where you can regularly practice shooting so you'll be steady, smart and proficient when the moment comes, God forbid, that you brandish that weapon to protect you and/or your family.  (Will you ever really have the time and the dedication to become a good shot?)

My thoughts turn inevitably to the subject of buyer's remorse.

I have to believe there are a lot of people who, months or years after spending a thousand dollars or more on a handgun, look up at that thing on the top shelf of their closet in a calm moment and ask themselves, What was I thinking?  






To Reduce Anxiety, Vaccine Program Should Have Had Central Booking

Sunday, February 28, 2021

The psychological impacts of how one is required to obtain  a COVID-19 vaccination in Massachusetts could have been foreseen, but, understandably, they were not: our state has never before attempted to vaccinate more than four million citizens in a compressed timeframe during a global pandemic.

Today, most Massachusetts citizens who want to get a shot for COVID-19 -- unlike their counterparts, say, in New Jersey or Florida or New Mexico -- have to get on a new state website and hunt for their own appointment at the same time that hundreds of thousand of other folks are hunting too. With demand for shots far exceeding supply, the large majority of vaccine seekers have not succeeded in securing these coveted appointments.  

People are spending long periods on computers filling out the required form, only to be told at the expected culmination of the process that there are no available appointments and they'll have to try again later.  When they sign off, all the information they have provided vanishes, meaning they'll have to fill out the form again (and again) until one day they get lucky. 

If the Governor Baker administration had, instead, incorporated a central registration feature into its electronic sign-ups, as some other states have done, persons would have filled out the form only once and subsequently been notified when appointments in their areas became available.

No system designed in a hurry to deal with an unprecedented national medical emergency would ever have been perfect, and I'm sure there are some drawbacks and downsides to a system built around central registration; however, one of the beauties of central registration is that it provides users with an instant feeling of accomplishment or progress.  People feel: "I'm in the system.  They know me. It's a just matter of time before I get my shot."

By contrast, in Massachusetts, way too many folks who are doing what they are instructed to do, and failing repeatedly to secure an appointment, have become frustrated and obsessed about when, or even whether, they'll be able to get a shot.  They feel:  "I've put hours into this and gotten nowhere.  Next week, I'll have to do it again -- and probably strike out again.  I'm on the outs.  And no one cares."  

Mass frustration with the COVID-19 vaccine finder website is overshadowing the actual good results of this program.

As of last Wednesday, Feb. 24, 1,084,888 persons had received at least one dose of a vaccine, and 433,593 persons had received both doses.  Also, 77% of vaccine doses shipped here by the federal government had been administered.

Massachusetts is best in the nation for first doses administered per capita among states with five million or more citizens, and ranks second in the nation for percentage of Black residents who have gotten at least one shot.  

Also, Massachusetts has administered more than three times the doses per capita as the European Union and more than five times per capita as Canada.

State Senator Diane DiZoglio, D-Methuen, has filed a bill that would require the Executive Office of Health and Human Services to institute a central registration system for COVID-19 vaccinations.  If I were the governor, I'd pre-empt that by ordering EOHHS to implement such a system as soon as possible.  Right away people would feel better about the program.  And maybe they'd start thinking about the good things the administration has done in fighting the pandemic.


HEAD-SPINNING NUMBERS: During a virtual hearing this past Thursday of the legislature's Joint Committee on COVID-19 and Emergency Preparedness, Charlie Baker was asked for the numbers on federal pandemic aid to the Commonwealth.  His answer made me sit up and take notice.  Seventy-one billion dollars has come to Massachusetts one way or another through four major federal relief programs, Baker said, adding that $20 billion-plus of that went to unemployment insurance, $27 billion to Payroll Protection Program benefits for businesses, and $8 billion to stimulus checks for individuals and families.  It's hard to imagine how badly we'd be doing now without that help from Washington.

UPDATE, 3-11-21: Gov. Baker announced yesterday that the Commonwealth will be implementing this Friday a new pre-registration system for residents seeking a COVID-19 vaccination. They will be able to fill out a form online or by phone, which will put them in a virtual queue for appointments.  On a first-registered, first-serve basis, registrants will then be notified when an appointment is available at one of the seven large, regional vaccination sites near them.





Oh Happy Day When COVID Ends...but a Bigger Test Is Coming

Wednesday, February 17, 2021

The COVID-19 pandemic is not the biggest test of our nation's strength and character.  That will come after, when we decide what we will do (or not) about the inequities revealed by the pandemic.

Based on how the U.S. responded to similar inequities after the last pandemic, the Spanish Flu of 1918-20, there's reason to expect we will fail the post-COVID-19 test, with terrible consequences for our country.

A great deal has been written and said about how some population groups have been hurt more deeply than others during the current pandemic; no single post could summarize all the evidence of such impacts. Here are just two examples:

  • Last summer, the COVID-19 Health Equity Advisory Group of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health reported that Black non-Hispanic residents and Hispanic residents in our Commonwealth have a three-times higher positive coronavirus case rate than white, non-Hispanic residents, and that Black and Hispanic residents also have higher rates of hospitalizations and deaths compared to white or Asian residents.
  • In the Fall 2020 edition of "Harvard Public Health," the magazine of the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Madeline Drexler wrote, "Today's coronavirus pandemic is the only public health crisis in the last hundred years as profoundly disruptive to society as the 1918 flu.  And like the 1918 pandemic, it has unmasked persistent racial injustice.  According to the COVID Racial Data Tracker, one of the most reliable sources of data on racial disparities in today's catastrophe, as of September 1, 2020, COVID-19 had killed at least 36,320 Black people in the U.S.  A collaboration between the COVID Tracking Project and the Boston University Center for Antiracist Research, the Racial Data Tracker also found that while Black people make up 13 percent of the U.S. population, they account for 22 percent of deaths in which race is known.  Black Americans are dying from COVID-19 at 2.4 times the rate of white people."

The Spanish Flu killed somewhere between 50 million and 100 million around the world, including up to 850,000 in the U.S., about .81% of our population at the time.  Those deaths were a collective shock to the nation unlike anything else in history.  Yet, within a few years, the shock effects had worn off and Americans were reveling in the prosperity of the Roaring 20s.  

Long ago, I read somewhere that one reason we seemed to move on quickly from those 850,000 deaths was that immigrants, desperate for a new start in America, quickly replaced those who had been taken by the flu.

Today, the COVID-19 death toll in the US stands at around 489,000.  We don't know how much worse it will get.  Let's be hopeful, optimistic; let's say U.S. deaths will top off at 525,000.    

The U.S. could admit that number of immigrants in 2022, if it wanted to. (Maybe we should for reasons totally unrelated to COVID-19.)  And if we happened to do that, let us hope that, when 2023 rolls around, the U.S. is seriously addressing racial and economic injustices rather than mindlessly enjoying prosperity's rebirth.    

I'll end with an excerpt from a recent report by the Center for Employment Equity at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. Written by Donald Tomaskovic-Devey, Rodrigo Dominguez-Villegas and Eric Hoyt, the report was titled, "The COVID-19 Recession: An Opportunity to Reform Our Low Wage Economy?"

"If the recovery from the COVID-19 recession follows the path of the 2007-2009 Great Recession, it will generate mainly low-wage, low quality jobs, and we as a nation will have embraced our past failings yet again.  The ability of the U.S. to respond to crises of any sort depends on the resiliency of its people and institutions.  If we do not make access to health care, sick and family leave, and living wages a social right before the next economic crisis -- whether it is financial, viral , or some new surprise -- we will have failed again to learn the shameful lessons of our own history.  If we do not disrupt the power dynamics that leave most workers exposed to insecurity and poverty level employment, we will leave our country vulnerable to economic and social collapse, perhaps now, certainly in future crises -- whether economic or political."






  

In Grim Week at the Capitol, MA Politicians Were at Least Voices of Sanity

Saturday, January 30, 2021

Until this week, I believed that the Trump propaganda campaign alleging Joe Biden "stole" the election would collapse, perhaps soon, under the astonishing weight of its own absurdity.

Then two things happened: 45 Republican members of the U.S. Senate voted for a measure asserting that a Trump impeachment trial would be unconstitutional, which strongly suggested Trump will be acquitted at trial of inciting the January 6 attack on the Capitol; and Kevin McCarthy, the Republican minority leader in the U.S. House, who has backtracked from an initial statement that Trump bore some responsibility for the attack, made a special trip to Mar-a-Lago to kiss Trump's ring and make up.

I think now that Trump will be able to sustain the big lie for many months, if not years, to come.  

Crime does pay. 

The truth that Trump lost appears to be gaining acceptance generally in the country, but the lie that Biden stole the presidency is still held dear by a large majority of Republicans.  According to poll results announced five days ago by the Monmouth University (NJ) Polling Institute, "...fully 72% of Republicans persist in believing that Biden's win is due to voter fraud."

Patrick Murray, director of the institute, said, "A number of ostensible leaders in the Republican Party continue to peddle this false narrative and many more who know this claim is wrong have not been particularly outspoken in disavowing it.  Their fellow partisans in the American public are simply following that lead."

Trump has to be spending most of his days in Florida laughing. Who needs evidence when you've got partisans like this?

The only bright spot for me this week were comments by two Massachusetts congressmen and one former Massachusetts governor condemning the most out-there Republican to come along in years, Marjorie Taylor Greene.

Greene is the gun-toting, venom-spewing, Stop-the-Steal-embracing, newly elected congresswoman from Georgia's ultra-red 14th District.  Please Google her if you want to glimpse the scope of her awfulness.  I'll give just one example: in January, 2019, she "liked" the sentiment, expressed somewhere on the Internet, that "a bullet to the head" would be a good way of removing Speaker Nancy Pelosi from the House.  

Needless to say, Greene liked the way her fellow "patriots" took the law into their own hands on January 6. Before the mayhem erupted, she called the electoral college count protest a "1776 moment."

A spokesman for McCarthy described Greene's comments on social media as "deeply disturbing" and said his boss "plans to have a conversation with the Congresswoman about them."  

Note to McCarthy: Make sure Greene goes through a metal detector before sitting down for that tete-a-tete. 

Yesterday, Jake Auchincloss (like Greene, a rookie in the House) tweeted: "The GOP knew what it was getting well before Marjorie Taylor Greene when it embraced Donald Trump in 2016 -- that is really when a ticking time bomb began.  GOP leaders own this issue and they all need to take ownership of removing this faction of white supremacy and extremism."

Jim McGovern, who has served in the House for 24 years, tweeted Friday, "This is sick. What the hell is going on with you @GOP Leader McCarthy?  You won't even condemn extremists in your own Republican Conference who advocated for the execution of a member of Congress.  What a disgrace.  Both of you should resign."

Mitt Romney, our governor from 2003 to 2007, and now a Senator from Utah, was quoted today in Politico saying: "Lies of a feather flock together: Marjorie Taylor Greene's nonsense and the 'big lie' of a stolen election."

Meanwhile, Congresswoman Greene is taking a play from her hero Trump's book, using  the controversy she ignited to turbocharge her fundraising on the Internet.  


If DiCarlo Hadn't Messed Up, Would Bulger Still Have Become Senate President?

Saturday, January 23, 2021

Joseph C. DiCarlo died on Tuesday, October 20, 2020, at the age of 84. The notice of his death appeared in The Boston Globe five days later.  It said he had waged a courageous battle against cancer and "left this world peacefully, bathed in spirit, beauty and love." It listed his survivors, who include his wife of 62 years, his three children and their spouses, four grandchildren, one great-grandchild, three brothers and a sister-in-law. (A fourth brother had died before him.)  The notice ended with a suggestion of an end-of-life care agency to which the aggrieved could make contributions in DiCarlo's name; a statement that funeral services would be private; and the website of the funeral home handling the arrangements, where persons could leave written condolences.

There was nothing in the notice about DiCarlo's professional activities, nor about his substantial accomplishments in the political arena.  Once a highly regarded public schoolteacher, he had been elected from his hometown of Revere to both the Massachusetts House and Senate back in the Sixties.  In the Senate, he  represented a three-county district anchored in Revere and encompassing the communities of Everett, Saugus and Winthrop. 

In the upper branch, DiCarlo rose and flourished like a fast-growing pine.  

First elected to the Senate in 1968, he was by 1971 the Assistant Majority Leader of the Democrats. 

Senate President Kevin Harrington of Salem promoted him to Majority Leader in 1973. 

There was nothing in the death notice to indicate he had once been a powerful figure on Beacon Hill, a politician of natural gifts perceived as a likely future president of the Senate and even as a potential governor of the Commonwealth one day.

Newspaper death notices are not obituaries, which are news stories on the deceased written by reporters.  Rather, they are customary advertisements paid for by families of the deceased and placed by funeral directors at the behest of families. Families put what they want into death notices and omit what they don't want.

To my knowledge, no Boston-based newspaper, television or radio station produced a standard, comprehensive obituary on Joe DiCarlo.  If one had, they almost certainly would have mentioned his federal district court conviction in 1977 on charges related to the shakedown of a construction management company, McKee-Berger-Mansueto, which was responsible for supervising the construction of the UMass Boston campus. This became known as "the MBM scandal."

DiCarlo and another member of the Senate, Ronald C. MacKenzie, a Republican from Burlington, had been jointly charged and convicted in the case. They were found to have extorted money from MBM in exchange for ensuring that a Senate oversight committee would render a favorable report on the company's planning and quality control work at the newly-relocated/newly-built university complex at Columbia Point.

In a February 26, 1977, article, "2 Massachusetts State Senators Are Convicted in Extortion Case," The New York Times reported:

"The Senators were both found guilty of the entire eight-count Federal indictment.  It included one count of violating the Hobbs Act, which makes it illegal to extort money under threat of economic injury or through the misuse of public office; five counts of violating the Federal Travel Act, which outlaws the use of interstate transportation or communications in connection with the committing of an illegal act, and one count each of conspiracy to violate the Hobbs Act and conspiracy to violate the Travel Act....

"Senator MacKenzie was accused of taking money from the construction company on at least five different occasions.  Senator DiCarlo was not accused of actually taking money, but was charged with being part of the 'criminal venture' because he was chairman of the committee that was investigating the construction contract." 

After their convictions, DiCarlo and MacKenzie both refused to resign from the Senate, so action to expel them commenced.  

On March 31, 1977, the day before the Senate Ethics Committee issued its report on their offenses, MacKenzie resigned.  DiCarlo continued to resist calls for his resignation.  

On April 4, 1977, the full Senate voted 28 to 8 to expel DiCarlo, the first time any member of the body had ever been thrown out like that.  DiCarlo then ran in the special election held to fill his seat -- and lost to a young alderman from Everett, Frank Mastrocola.  

DiCarlo and MacKenzie served nine and ten months, respectively, in federal prison.

After doing time, DiCarlo and MacKenzie became model citizens.  DiCarlo worked in various professional jobs.  The disbarred MacKenzie, after working for years as a paralegal, won back his license to practice law.

DiCarlo was 41 years old when his life in politics came crashing down, meaning he lived another 43 years.  I do not think it's fair to define Joe DiCarlo's 84 years on earth by the MBM scandal 

None of us wants to be judged entirely by our worst choice, our darkest moment, our biggest mistake, nor should most of us be so judged. 

Some of us pay a much stiffer price for our mistakes than others. 

That was true for DiCarlo, MacKenzie and countless other public office malefactors through the ages. Their falls from grace, their public shamings, their ruined political careers, exceed by geometric proportions the defeats and humiliations endured by average (private) citizens. 

As justice required, DiCarlo and MacKenzie paid dearly for their transgressions.  And, long ago,  they earned the right to forgiveness.

As I see it, there's only one good reason now to resurrect this case.  At the time of his indictment and arrest, Joe DiCarlo was a certifiable political phenomenon, a charismatic, silver-tongued orator in the prime of life. He was riding high in the legislature, the odds-on favorite to succeed the near legendary Harrington.

As it turned out, the man Harrington named to replace DiCarlo as majority leader was William Bulger of South Boston, who, in the following year, 1978, would be elected by his peers as Harrington's successor.  

For the next 17 years, Bulger ruled over the Senate, accumulating and wielding great power. He had a run at the top unlike that of any comparable Massachusetts figure in modern times.

Maybe Bulger would have become Senate President one day whether or not DiCarlo got into trouble with the feds.  Maybe not.  Maybe the stars were aligned for him only in that precise moment 42 years ago and would never again line up with such force and  finality.  In one sense, it is not at all a stretch to regard the late Joe DiCarlo as the man who made Bill Bulger.