Advice to Auchincloss: Success Isn't Maneuvering for National Import

Sunday, September 27, 2020

Jake Auchincloss, age 32, won the seven-person Democratic congressional primary election to succeed Joe Kennedy in the Fourth Massachusetts District and is heavily favored to beat the Republican nominee in the November 3 final, Julie Hall.  Based on the way he has campaigned -- promising to oppose President Trump's agenda at every turn -- we can expect Auchincloss to spend a lot of time in Washington on big national controversies.  If I had his ear, I'd counsel otherwise.  And I'd hold up the example of South Boston's Joe Moakley (1927-2001) on how better to become a serious legislator, a force to be reckoned with, an endearing figure, in the U.S. House.

Before his 28-year run in the Congress (1973-2001) in the old Ninth District, Moakley served as a state representative (1953-1960), a state senator (1965-1970) and a Boston city councilor (1971-72).  At the State House, Boston City Hall, and the Capitol in D.C., he was known for his geniality, sense of humor, common touch, dedication to constituent services, and ability to establish trust with members of the opposing party and, generally, anybody who held  an opposing viewpoint.  With the help of his friend and fellow congressman, Thomas P. "Tip" O'Neill, Speaker of the House from 1977 to 1987, Moakley moved unobtrusively up the ladder until he was appointed, in 1989, as chair of the powerful House Rules Committee, which has critical, discretionary power to set the terms for debating and voting on bills.  He leveraged that power to deliver federal funding for such major projects as the clean-up of Boston Harbor and other big infrastructure works in Massachusetts.     

Jim McGovern, the congressman for the Worcester-centered Second Massachusetts District since 1997, got his start in politics as an aide to Joe Moakley and became an indispensable part of Moakley's operation during his time on the staff (1981-96).  Four days after Moakley's June 2, 2001, funeral at St. Brigid's Church in South Boston, McGovern sponsored a House resolution registering the "profound sorrow" of members upon Moakley's passing and recording the adjournment of the House that day "as a further mark of respect to the memory of the deceased."  Here, in part, is what McGovern said on that occasion:

"Mr. Speaker, I had a front-row seat to watch a real master in action. Joe was guided by the simple but powerful principle that no one is unimportant.  From the streets of South Boston to the jungles of El Salvador, Joe Moakley stood for and fought for fairness, and fought for justice.  He made sure that Mrs. O'Leary got her lost Social Security check.  He fought to make sure that our veterans got the health care services that they were entitled to receive.  He cared deeply about the environment, and he had a passion for civil rights and equal rights and human rights.

"And yes, Mr. Speaker, he was a Democrat and very, very proud of it.  He believed in the Democratic Party and he fought hard for the principles and values that he believed in.  But, as I am sure that my Republican colleagues will acknowledge, Joe respected and admired those who had different views and even a different party affiliation.  Joe Moakley was a people person and his influence and his power in this institution was based not merely on his seniority or his status on the Committee on Rules but instead it was based on personal relationships and friendships with men and women of both parties.   

"His advice to me after I first got elected to Congress was not to give the most fiery or partisan speeches or even to hire the most experienced or expensive press secretary, but to get to know everyone on a first-name basis.  Building coalitions and building friendships, he would say, was the surest way to be effective."

Close to a thousand persons attended Moakley's funeral Mass, including the nation's top Republican at the time, President George W. Bush, and the man then third-in-line to the presidency, the Republican Speaker of the House, J. Dennis Hastert of Illinois. Many thousands more watched the rites on television.  

Anne E. Kornblut, who covered the funeral for The Boston Globe, noted that Bush had met Moakley only twice, and only after becoming President, five months before Moakley's death.  Bush's advisors told Kornblut that the president's attendance "was motivated purely by personal respect" for Moakley.  She quoted Ari Fleischer, Bush's press secretary, as saying,  "He (Bush), on his visits with the congressman, instantly came to the same conclusions that everybody else has, about what a wonderful man Congressman Moakley was, his human touch.  The good-natured spirit that Congressman Moakley brought to the job moved the president."

A little more than five months ago, on April 21, a retired professor by the name of Richard F. Fenno, Jr., a native of Winchester, Massachusetts, who held a Ph.D. in history from Harvard, passed away at age 93 at his home in Rye, New York.  Fenno taught at the University of Rochester for five decades and wrote 19 books, most focusing on the U.S. House and Senate.  One of his final books, "Congressional Travels: Places, Connections, and Authenticity," was inspired, according to a New York Times obituary on Fenno, "by the national attention and bipartisan affection accorded to a relatively anonymous House member, John Joseph Moakley."

Intrigued, I purchased a copy of  "Congressional Travels..." online.  Here are three key excerpts from Chapter 1, which is titled, "A Story About Place: Joe Moakley's Funeral":

"...a House member's designation, as prescribed in the U.S. Constitution, is not Congressman, it is Representative.  And whereas 'congressman' or 'congresswoman' tends to call our attention to a House member's Capitol Hill activities and to his or her relationship with colleagues, 'representative' points us toward a House member's activities in his or her home district and to relationships with constituents."

"I believe that while the examination of Joe Moakley's activities and relationships in Washington provides, at best, a weak explanation of the ceremony after his death, an examination of his activities and relationships in his home constituency provides a strong explanation.  We could know all there was to know about Moakley's life in Washington and not explain the attendance at his funeral.  I will argue that he was not a memorable congressman but he was a memorable representative.  The story of his funeral should not be read as a national story at all.  It was primarily a local story."

"Joe Moakley can be known best as someone with recognizable connections to a place and to a constituency, for it is these connections -- and the strength of these connections -- that made him a remarkable politician.  Therefore, answers to the question 'What is he like?' cannot be found in Washington.  They can only be found at home.  Answers to the question 'Why did so many people come to memorialize him?' can only be found at home.  Joe Moakley was indeed, 'a heavyweight' -- not in Washington, but at home."

Professor Fenno saw Moakley as a "local hero," if you will, and not a figure of national import.  I think Moakley might have objected to that assessment; I certainly object. 

Toward the end of his career, Moakley said that he considered his efforts to cut U.S. military assistance to El Salvador and to force legal action against those responsible for the 1989 murder at the University of Central America in San Salvador, the capital, of six Jesuit priests, their housekeeper and the housekeeper's daughter to be his "greatest achievement."

All his life, no matter what position, situation or contest he happened to be in, Moakley stuck to his fundamental principles and instincts.  He followed his principles and instincts wherever they led them, and to the end point of wherever they led.  That made him a great representative of his district, a great champion of our nation's ideals, and a figure of historical importance.

I'm sure that young Jake Auchincloss would like to achieve great things, to perform deeds worthy of history books.  Assuming he'll get the opportunity to serve on Capitol Hill, I'd encourage him to resist the urge to be give fiery and/or partisan speeches every time a microphone or TV camera is available. I'd tell him to keep in mind instead the example of Joe Moakley, who never forgot where he came from (and lived his whole life), South Boston's Ward 7 peninsula, and who remained faithful all his days to the humble tenets of his upbringing and neighborhood.  


Bad Form to Hit a Guy When He's Down, but Somebody's Got to Do It

Friday, September 4, 2020

A great deal has been spoken and written about Kennedy's loss to Markey in the Democratic primary election for U.S. Senator this past Monday.  

The best, most succinct post-mortem I've read was in Politico, "Why Joe Kennedy's Senate campaign flopped": 

https://www.politico.com/news/2020/09/02/joe-kennedy-senate-campaign-failed-408033

I could not improve upon that.  But there are three brief comments I'd like to add:

One, Kennedy was not bold enough out of the gate. He seemed a bit sheepish, almost apologetic, about challenging the 44-year incumbent.  Result: The chance to make a strong and/or dramatic introduction of his candidacy was squandered.

Two, Kennedy's campaign photography never exploited his intrinsic physical/theatrical advantages, i.e., his youthful good looks and young person's energy/vitality.  Where were the billboards with the gigantic, side-by-side pictures of in-his-prime Joe next to ready-for-Medicare Eddie?  Scott Brown, who helped earn his way through college as a model, would not have made such a mistake.

Three, Kennedy missed badly when he fired at Markey in the second half of August for supposedly questioning his family legacy and "weaponizing" his family name in the video ad that went viral, "The Green New Dealmaker."   The ad was not the cheap shot Kennedy claimed it was.  Voters get that politics is a rough business.  They're stingy with sympathy when a politician gets banged up, especially when that politician has benefited from inherited wealth and privilege.

On the upside, I don't think all the talk about Joe being the first Kennedy to lose an election in Massachusetts has to mean anything in the end.  Plenty of successful high elective office-holders have come back from painful defeats to win the next election.  Think Charlie Baker, long the nation's most popular governor, who got spanked by Deval Patrick in 2010.

Defeat can be the best teacher if faced head-on, dispassionately. 

Joe Kennedy is a smart, selfless, experienced public servant, a person of impeccable character and integrity.  Idealism burns incandescently within him.  I hope it will not be long before his name appears again on a statewide ballot.

Footnote, re: Hometown Knockdown:   Alex Morse, now serving his fourth consecutive term as mayor of Holyoke, came up short Sept. 1 in his own backyard.  Holyoke voters favored incumbent Richie Neal in the Dem primary for U.S. representative in the First Massachusetts District by a 426-vote margin: Neal received 4,366 votes in Holyoke to Morse's 3,940.


  


  

Trump Would Never 'Get' Our Bump. Sad.

Monday, August 31, 2020

Three months ago, in the first week of June, State Auditor Suzanne Bump, then the president of the National Association of State Auditors, hosted a virtual conference of the association from her office at the Massachusetts State House. 

On the afternoon of the second full day of the conference, Wednesday, June 3, Bump could see, from her office window, a steady stream of protesters walking past the State House on Bowdoin Street, heading down the hill to Cambridge Street.  These were people outraged by the May 25 killing of George Floyd by police in Minneapolis.  

The sight of the marchers moved her so much that she incorporated her reaction to it into her prepared, closing remarks to the conferees the next day.  Describing the scene on Bowdoin Street, Bump, who served in the legislature as a rep from Braintree for eight years and has been state auditor since 2011, said: 

"For nearly 30 minutes, they streamed by my office window.  The peaceful protesters, many white, mostly young, signs aloft, loudly chanting, many with arms upraised, marching for a righteous cause, filled my eyes with tears, and my heart with a jumble of sorrow, hope, guilt, concern, gratitude and resolve.  The knee that indifferently snuffed out the life of George Floyd also unleashed a nation's collective disgust at, and, I hope, determination to directly confront the stain that we have sought to ignore since the founding of our nation. Our persistent, institutionalized racism can no longer be glossed over."

Bump continued, "So many individuals through the years have made their contributions to the righting of society's and government's wrongs.  I have liked to think, and had even managed to convince myself, that I have been on the right side of the moral equation, with my work in my community, with my votes as a legislator, with my actions as the state's auditor, pointing out inconsistencies in the criminal justice system and in access to services, and more recently deficiencies in police training.

"Whatever good intentions have motivated me, whatever good I actually have done, I now recognize, simply has not been enough to fulfill my obligations to my sisters and brothers of color or my country."  [bold face added]

She emphasized that "I have it within my power as a human being to be a stronger voice, to lend a firmer hand.  I have it within my power as an employer to set still higher standards, to instill greater awareness, and to provide a better example.  I have it within my power as an elected official to contribute to a better understanding of the ways that our government institutions fail to recognize and repair the damage inflicted by centuries of injustice.  All those things and more, I can, must and will do." [bold face added]

I became aware of these comments through a blast email from Bump's office on Friday, June 5.  They made a favorable impression and I made a mental note to maybe include them in a future blog post. Then I pretty much forgot about them until they came to mind, unbidden, while watching Donald Trump accept the Republican re-nomination for the presidency this past Thursday night.   

In that norm-shattering campaign speech from the grounds of the White House, Trump had not one gentle word, not one respectful or conciliatory gesture, for the millions of Americans hurt and angered by the killings of Black men by police.  I didn't expect Trump to take the soul-searching approach of a Suzanne Bump to the problem, but I was hoping he might acknowledge,  at least in  passing, the anguish, the frustration, that so many of his fellow citizens are experiencing.

Instead, it was clear that Trump will do everything possible over the next several weeks to make Joe Biden and the Democrats, not racial injustice and inequality, the issue.  

"If you give power to Joe Biden," he said, "the radical left will defund police departments all across America.  They will pass federal legislation to reduce law enforcement nationwide.  They will make every city look like Democrat-run Portland, Oregon.  No one will be safe in Biden's America.  My administration will always stand with the men and women of law enforcement."

For their audacity and creativity, we have to give Trump and the Republican Party credit.  Their virtual convention was a masterpiece of positioning and communicating -- up there with the best TV infomercials of all time. I cannot explain that better than a letter-writer to The New York Times, Ramesh Harihara. In a piece published two days after the GOP convention, Harihara wrote:

"The Republican production effort was stellar -- from the quality of videos, to the locations, to the attempt to show President Trump as someone who welcomes immigrants and is not a racist, to painting Covid as something in the past, and the awesome fireworks and opera at the end.  As a marketer I admire professionals who can take a deeply troubled product, puff up your chest and make people forget the failures." 

Every day from now until Nov. 3, Trump is going to say and do something bold to make voters forget his failures and to focus instead on how awful life will be in "Biden's America." Tomorrow, for example, Trump's going to Kenosha, Wisconsin.  When there, do you think he'll be soothing, or stoking, the passions unleashed by the shooting, and paralyzing, by police of  Jacob Blake on Aug. 23?

When both the Democratic governor and lieutenant governor of Wisconsin made public appeals to Trump over the weekend, asking him not to come to Kenosha  -- "The city was on fire and we need healing, not a barrel of gasoline rolling in," said Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes -- I knew there was no way Trump would not go.  Gasoline is practically his middle name.

To stop Trump's forward progress coming out of the convention and to beat him on Nov. 3, Biden will have to show some stuff, he will have make some moves, like we've never seen from him before.  Worried Dems are right.



Words Matter. Therein May Lie an Insight into Pelosi Boosting JPK III.

Tuesday, August 25, 2020

U.S. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi served side-by-side in the House with Edward J. Markey, our state's junior U.S. Senator, for 26 years, from 1987 to 2013. That did not inhibit her last week from endorsing Markey's challenger in the Sept. 1 Democratic primary for U.S. Senator, U.S. Rep. Joseph P. Kennedy, III.

The speaker said she was motivated by appreciation of Kennedy's critical work in raising funds and campaigning for Democratic candidates for the House in 2018, which contributed to the party's regaining the House majority and to Pelosi's ability to secure the speakership for the second time in her history-making career.

Politico reported that an aide to the speaker said. "...Pelosi was also concerned after the Markey campaign started ramping up its attacks on the Kennedy name, 'going after Joe, his family, his supporters and the Kennedy family policy legacy.' "

Her support of the Kennedys goes back to her beginnings in Baltimore.  Her father, Thomas D'Alessandro, Jr., a former Baltimore mayor (1947-59), was a prominent organizer and campaigner for John F. Kennedy in his bid for the presidency.  That was 60 years ago.

The speaker had good reasons for injecting herself into the fierce contest between Senator Markey and Rep. Kennedy.  

She also had reasons enough to give the race a good leaving-alone:

One, Pelosi had made it a policy point in her new speakership not to get involved in Democratic congressional primaries.  As soon as she broke her own rule, progressives in her party, such as Andrea Ocasio Cortez, known nationwide by her initials, AOC, wasted no time in calling her a hypocrite.

Two, young Joe Kennedy -- let's call him JPK III -- never asked Pelosi for her endorsement.  (Do you go where you're not invited?)

Three, endorsements are almost always a mixed bag in politics.  For every analyst who thinks they matter there's another who asserts they're insignificant.  

Indeed, there was evidence that Pelosi's thumb on the scales gave an immediate boost to Markey's fundraising.  

The Boston Globe reported this past Saturday, Aug. 22, that: (a) "the Kennedy campaign said it raised more than $100,000, mostly in small donations, on the heels of the high-profile endorsement," and (b) "the Markey campaign said...it raised more than $300,000, via roughly 9,000 individual donations, since Pelosi announced her endorsement of Kennedy."

The timing of the endorsement perhaps offers deeper insight into the speaker's decision.  But before I go into that, I want to state that Markey deserves to be returned to the Senate and that I have already voted early for him.

Pelosi endorsed JPK III shortly after a video advertisement for Markey went viral.  You may have seen or heard of this product, titled "The Green New Dealmaker."  It offered a new twist on President Kennedy's immortal statement at his inaugural: "Ask not what your country can do for you.  Ask what you can do for your country."

Highlighting how hard the pandemic has been on the nation's essential workers, the majority of whom earn low wages, Markey concludes the video by saying, "We asked what we can do for our country.  We went out, we did it.  With all due respect, it's time to start asking what your country can do for you." 

Given the state of our nation today, that formulation was not inappropriate, nor was it disrespectful of the Kennedys.  I don't get how it could have riled up the speaker to the point she'd violate her own policy and feed dissension in her House.

There was one thing about "The Green New Dealmaker," however, that I could see ticking Pelosi off to the point that she just had to speak out publicly on Markey v. Kennedy.

At a pivot point in the ad, an ultra-serious Markey comes into view, facing the camera head-on, and declares, "Well, they call me the dealmaker!"  

Shortly, he announces, "I put the deal on the table but the people make it impossible to refuse. With 500 laws on the books, do you think I'm gonna stop now?  [dramatic pause] They wish!"

Could it be this simple?  Ed Markey had an 11-year jump on Nancy Pelosi in the U.S. House and she got to be speaker.  Who's the dealmaker here?



 

It Was Probably Not a Great Idea, Anyway, for Morse to Take on Neal

Thursday, August 13, 2020

There's an aphorism often attributed (erroneously) to Sun Tzu, a Chinese general in the 5th Century B.C. who wrote a still popular book called "The Art of War." It goes like this, "If you wait by the river long enough, the bodies of your enemies will float by."

I think Springfield's Richie Neal, chairman of Ways & Means in the U.S. House of Representatives, just had a body-of-his-enemy-floating-by moment.

Neal's opponent in the western Massachusetts congressional district Democratic primary on September 1, Holyoke Mayor Alex B. Morse, was accused in a recent letter from the College Democrats of Massachusetts of using his position as a part-time, visiting UMass faculty member "for romantic or sexual gain."

The letter, and an article on the letter, were published this past Friday, August 7, in the Massachusetts Daily Collegian, a student-run publication.  The allegedly inappropriate behavior by Morse centered on three issues, the article stated:

"The first issue alleges that Morse regularly matched with students on dating apps, including Tinder and Grindr, who were as young as 18 years old.  These students included members of the College Democrats of Massachusetts, UMass Amherst Democrats and other groups in the state.

"The second issue, 'Using Democrats' events to meet college students and add them on Instagram, adding them to his 'Close Friends' story and DMing them, both of which have made young college students uncomfortable.' 

"The third issue, 'Having sexual contact with college students, including at UMass Amherst, where he teaches, and the greater Five College Consortium.' " (Consortium members are UMass, Amherst, Hampshire, Mt. Holyoke and Smith Colleges.)

Morse, in a statement to the Daily Collegian, reportedly admitted to having "consensual adult relationships, including some with college students" and "apologized to anyone I have made feel uncomfortable..."

This past Monday, a campaign spokesperson for Neal denied that Neal's campaign was involved in the publication of the allegations against Morse.

Morse said in a later radio interview that he believes Neal's campaign was involved.  "I think this is what happens when you go against power," he told the interviewer on public radio station WAMC.

If Neal or anyone affiliated with his re-election effort were involved, that fact will almost certainly come to light, sooner or later.  There are too many persons in the College Democrats of Massachusetts for them all to keep that secret for long.  That's why I don't believe that Neal, et al., were involved: it would be too risky, it could blow up in his face, he could end up looking scared or like a bully.  

Neal is obviously the favorite in the primary, despite all of the energy and money progressive Democrats have poured into the Morse campaign, as they did into the (successful) congressional campaigns of Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez and Ayanna Pressley.  

(I respect progressives as much as the next guy from Massachusetts. But, even if these accusations against Morse had never been hurled, I can't see how his candidacy gets over the fact that a Morse victory would take Neal out of D.C. when, after 31 years in Congress, he is at the height of his powers and most able to deliver the goods to his district and state.)

Neal has been a student of political warfare long enough to know that, as in most human endeavors, the most grievous wounds in politics are self-inflicted, and that patience and restraint tend to be rewarded.  It would surprise me not if Neal long ago committed to memory these words: 

"If you wait by the river long enough, the bodies of your enemies will float by."  

 




Blogster's Miscellany: Thoughts on Markey v. Kennedy, Plush Pensions & More

Friday, August 7, 2020

MEANINGLESS MEASUREMENTS DEPT.  The Boston Globe recently devoted just under 100 inches of type, plus a color photo and caption that spanned four columns and went four inches deep, to the campaign tempest over how much time U.S. Senator Ed Markey spends in Massachusetts versus Washington, D.C.  Headline: "Markey was least likely legislator to be in Mass." 

After reviewing travel records for all members of the Massachusetts congressional delegation, the Globe revealed that Markey stayed in Massachusetts on 38% of the nights between June 1, 2018, and May 31, 2020, whereas his opponent in the September 1 Democratic primary, U.S. Rep. Joseph P. Kennedy, III, spent 70% of those nights here. "Senator Markey isn't here enough.  He isn't in Massachusetts enough," Kennedy complains.  The article pointed out that, for every local official in the state who says Markey is never around, there is another who "says he is an engaged and present politician."  Where a member of congress bunks is a bogus metric -- and never more than in the era of the coronavirus and video meetings via electronics, i.e., Zoom, WebEx, et al.  And what about the carbon emissions resulting from all those congresspersons flying back and forth to Washington at the drop of a hat?  Enviros, why rush you not to Eddie's defense?

MORE MEANINGFUL MEASUREMENTS DEPT.  I miss President Obama as much as the next guy from Massachusetts.  That does not mean I agreed with everything he said and did -- or did not do.  I still shake my head over the time he was at the Gridiron Club event and dismissed the idea of socializing with the Senate Republican majority leader.  That day, in the middle of a very effective comedic routine, Obama told the audience of media bigshots, and friends of bigshots: "Some folks still don't think I spend enough time with Congress. 'Why don't you get a drink with Mitch McConnell?' they ask. 'Really? Why don't YOU get a drink with Mitch McConnell?"  How could someone as smart as Obama not see having a drink with the majority leader as a priority rather than a pointless chore?  This sets up a soapbox moment for me on the aforementioned Globe story...I believe a better measurement of congressional job performance than the number of nights spent at homes in their districts is how many times they have dinner in Washington with a member of the other party.

STATE PENSION WHIPPING BOY.  The Boston Herald published an article August 3 stating there are 1,540 retired state employees who "are set to earn six-figure payouts (of their pensions this year) as the state struggles mightily during the coronavirus pandemic, ["Massachusetts pensions keep bulging with state paying out $5.44B.  Herald analysis of state pension report shows slew of of six-figure earners."]   Here's the first paragraph of that article: "UMass retirees top the state's $5.44 billion pension system, with the university's former President William 'Billy' Bulger set to pocket nearly $272,000 this year, records show."  Bulger, who served as president of the Massachusetts Senate for 17 years before becoming president of UMass, is collecting the size pension allowed him under law.  Anyone else in his position would do the same.  That does not mean it is a good idea the state fails to put a cap on maximum earnings by state pensioners.  Something in the range of $5,000 to $6,000 a month ($60K-$72K per year) seems reasonable -- as well as prudent for a Commonwealth with so many unmet needs.  Perhaps the pandemic-related depression we're experiencing will create the social and political circumstances that will end, at some indistinct point in the future, six-figure pensions for future state retirees.   

FLEXIBILITY EQUALS LONGEVITY.  During a virtual U.S. senatorial campaign event on August 4 hosted by Suffolk University, the WGBH Forum Network and the Justice Reform Coalition, both Ed Markey and challenger Joe Kennedy supported: (a) ending prison sentences of life without parole, (b) decriminalizing sex work, and (c) giving incarcerated felons the right to vote.  When Markey was first elected to office 48 years ago, as a state rep from Malden, I strongly doubt he could have won if he'd espoused even one of those positions, never mind all three.  Today, I would bet, that Markey cannot win the September 1 Democratic primary if he does not to embrace all three...There's a huge difference between a race for rep in one or two communities and a statewide election for what is a national office.  The comparison is interesting but not apt.  So let's take the first time Markey was elected to the U.S. House from the old Seventh Massachusetts District, in 1976.  He won a very crowded, 12-person Democratic primary and then coasted to victory in the final. I covered that race as a newspaper reporter.  If Markey had made the mistake on the campaign trail then of even musing aloud on parole for lifers, lawful sex for hire, and inmate voting rights, the resulting controversy would have sunk his congressional candidacy; his 40-plus-year career in D.C. never would have happened.

ONE MAN'S BASE IS ANOTHER'S MAN'S MOB.  Talk about red meat!  Not long after the virtual U.S. senatorial campaign event hosted by Suffolk U., et al., the Massachusetts Republican Party issued a press release ripping Markey and Kennedy for their positions.  The headline on the release gives the complete flavor of the product: "Markey, Kennedy competing to see who can best placate the far-left mob."  Party chairman Jim Lyons, formerly a state rep from Andover, was quoted in the release as follows: "These dangerous proposals are where the Democrats are headed, and they're absolutely insane.  Both Sen. Markey and Rep. Kennedy will do anything and promise anything to pander to the far left mob that appears to be dictating the Democrat Party's policy platform."

IN A DESPERATE TIME, A NEEDED REMINDER.  Yesterday, Action for Boston Community Development issued a statement reminding us all how bad things are in our country at this moment -- and how much worse things may become if a new coronavirus relief law does not quickly emerge from the Congress and the office of the President.  ABCD points out that, when the emergency $600-per-week federal payment to every unemployed person expired seven days ago, on July 31, more than 950,000 Massachusetts were impacted, meaning that many families are now unable to meet their basic needs, and that, abruptly, there was a lot less money being spent in Massachusetts.  "...continuing delay in passage of a second virus relief bill leaves 30 million high and dry, running out of food and essential goods and fearing homelessness after the federal eviction moratorium ended July 25,"  ABCD noted. 


No One Wants to Think 'Bacteria' on a Beach Day. But You Better.

Thursday, July 30, 2020

We've obviously had a lot of great beach weather lately.  But one should be aware that, when it comes to swimming in Massachusetts, not all beaches are created equal.  

I'm not talking about the texture of the sand, the amount of seaweed, the number of parking spaces, or amenities like snack bars and rest rooms.  No, I'm talking about yucky stuff: bacteria in the water!

There are beaches in the Bay State where the chances are higher than average the water can make you sick, according to a recent report by the Boston-based Environment Massachusetts Research & Policy Center, known more commonly by its shorter name, Environment Massachusetts.  

"Along many areas of our coast, the water is cleaner than it used to be  -- but pollution remains a serious problem," says the organization's state director. Ben Hellerstein.  "All too often, our beaches aren't safe for swimming.  We can and must do a better job of keeping waste out of our water." 

Every summer, Environment Massachusetts issues a report, titled Safe for Swimming?, on the results of water tests conducted the previous year at hundreds of public beaches in the Commonwealth.

That report, available online at environmentmassachusetts.org, showed that, in 2019, there were "potentially unsafe levels of pollution on at least one day at 257 beaches in Massachusetts."  The key measurement of beach safety used in this analysis is the level of fecal bacteria.  

Contact with contaminated water may lead to gastrointestinal illnesses, respiratory diseases, ear and eye infections, skin rashes and more.

Tenean Beach in the Dorchester section of Boston "had the highest number of potentially unsafe swimming days in 2019, with tests revealing elevated levels of fecal bacteria on 44 out of 90 days tested," Environment Massachusetts reported.

The next highest number of potentially unsafe days were found at King's Beach, in Lynn and Swamscott, where there were 43; Malibu Beach, Dorchester, 20; Wollaston Beach at Channing Street, Quincy, 20; and Constitution Beach, East Boston, 19.

The state frequently tests the water at public beaches in the summer.  When elevated levels of bacteria are detected, signs are posted. It's important to look for these messages.

It has long been known that combined sewer overflows (CSOs) are the major cause of beach pollution.  CSOs occur during heavy rainstorms in communities where pipes carry both storm water and sewage and send the overflows into the ocean or rivers via "outfalls."   

Steep financial and logistical challenges confront any municipality that needs to address this problem, which is why it tends to persist for decades.

Advocates for change argue that, if cities, towns and other entities cannot correct CSOs through costly infrastructure upgrades, the least they can do is get the word out quickly to the public when CSOs occur.  This is especially critical in cases like that of the Merrimack River, where up-river outfalls automatically threaten down-river communities that draw water from the river for household uses, including drinking.

Concerns like this form the basis of a bill now before the Ways & Means Committee of the House of Representatives, House 3976, An Act Promoting Awareness of Sewage Pollution in Public Waters. If enacted into law, H.3976 would require any person or entity holding a permit allowing the discharge of sewage at outfalls to issue a public advisory within two hours of the discharge, and to upgrade that advisory "every eight hours for an ongoing discharge and within two hours (of) when a discharge ceases or is projected to cease..." Here's a link to the complete text of the bill:

https://malegislature.gov/Bills/191/H3976

We are now one day away from what, in a normal election year, would be the final day of formal sessions of the legislature, July 31, meaning H.3976 would almost certainly have failed to pass in a normal year.  Time would have run out on its chance to do some good.

Nothing is normal in the time of the coronavirus.  

The legislature is going to keep meeting formally, perhaps even until the end of this calendar year.  For this and many other good bills, there's still hope.